Tuesday, 21 May 2013

10 Things I Hate About Fundraising



It's Monday, the weather is rubbish, I missed my train and forgot my swimming stuff for my lunch time swim. Oh and I am back from annual leave.

I am, therefore, in a very grumpy mood and thought instead of writing deep and meaningful blogs about fundraising we could do a light hearted look at all that is wrong with it.

1. It is a job you are always failing at. Most people don’t want to give you money, run a marathon for you or hand their bank details over to your 'chugger' on the street.

2. The people that do want to give you money can be really easy to upset. You don’t thank the ones that want the thank you, you get told off for thanking the ones that didn’t (despite putting a tick box on the donation form). You don’t keep your regular givers up to date enough. You waste too much money keeping your regular givers up to date. Basically they want you to read their mind and we can’t!

3. The organisation you work for probably dislikes you. Your supporter care team think you are harassing people. Your programmes team think you are putting down your beneficiaries. Your finance team think you are not raising enough. Your HR team.....actually they probably don’t mind you and are possibly the only team that is stopping you from being the least popular people in the organisation.

4. Everyone can do your job better than you – EVERYONE. The rest of the organisation, your donors, your flatmates, your parents . For some reason it is a job everyone feels entitled to have an opinion on and the fact that you may have been working for years in fundraising counts for nothing 'cause your mum "was chatting to the Big Issue seller and he says chugging makes no money."

5. The money is rubbish. Say no more.

Now I think about it, I actually can’t think of 10 things I hate about fundraising – I am stuck on five!  

And number five I didn’t really mean. I just said it because a list of four doesn’t look right on my page layout. 

And number one is kind of why we love the job. Because when you do succeed it feels like such an achievement. 

And number two is unfair because for all the complaints and moaning and groaning, donors are lovely, kind and caring people. And they usually only complain because they care so much. 

Number three is petty. Whilst there are tensions and strains in all organisations we need them to do their job just as much as they need us to do ours. 

I stand by number four though. Number four is annoying.

So, to summarise I have a job that I can only think of one bad point for and that allows me to go swimming in my lunch break when I remember my stuff. 

Life is not too bad really, is it?

Kathryn Brooke


Tuesday, 16 April 2013

Celebrating fundraising: Musings on the National Awards


We're rapidly moving towards one of the highlights in any fundraiser's calendar - the Institute of Fundraising’s (IOF), National Convention. Which brings with it the annual celebration of the great and good of fundraising: the National Awards. 

Last week saw the unveiling of the full shortlist - and what a list it was!  The IOF tell us that this was a year with a record number of entries, and there is some fantastic fundraising on display.  I chatted with a handful of fundraisers who had had campaigns shortlisted to get some insight from them on what the shortlist tells us about the state of the sector, what it takes to be shortlisted, and their feelings about making the cut.
 

Contributions from:
Adrian Salmon - Footsteps Fund Manager, University of Leeds
Danielle Atkinson - Head of Digital & Individual Giving, Merlin
Katia de Gregorio – Head of Donor Marketing, Breakthrough Breast Cancer


I was struck by the diversity on offer in this year's shortlist. There are representatives from large and small organisations; household names to brand new charities; shiny new ideas and well-executed old-faithfuls.

Adrian was delighted to see representation from organisations that many wouldn’t realise are charities – two in academic fundraising, but also cultural and heritage organisations, like the Natural History Museum.  He points out that these organisations have a lot to offer back to the sector, particularly in the realms of major donor fundraising, and it’s fantastic seeing them recognised alongside the names that everyone identifies as charities.

Katia agrees: “It shows how competitive and diverse the sector is…(and) the range of causes shortlisted is broader than ever”.

It’s also a great reminder that top-class fundraising doesn’t have to be expensive.  Danielle points out: “there are smaller charities, who don't have the budgets of the big boys, thinking creatively and effectively to deliver the best fundraising possible”.  Certainly no-one could say that this is a list comprised of the “usual suspects”!

Katia was interested to note the innovation that the shortlist demonstrates – not purely within the “most innovative” category, but across the board; she says, “charities are embracing new ways to engage supporters – or using existing channels with new offers”.   This is one of the fantastic things about awards like this: “It’s great and inspiring to see how charities are adapting and using channels – or combinations of channels – in new ways”.

I wondered what it takes, aside from meeting the category criteria, to be shortlisted.  Both Katia and Danielle impress the importance of writing the entry itself well – with judges reading so very many entries, you need to make it simple for them to see at a glance why the campaign was so amazing and is worthy of shortlisting (and hopefully winning!). Danielle suggests bullet points for clarity and to save words (a nifty tip which makes a huge difference in this situation!).

Katia believes that, in this competitive world, “Good results don’t cut it anymore, they need to be exceptional” – and I think it’s worth remembering that exceptional results don’t necessarily have to mean raising hundreds of thousands of pounds.  Crucial, says Danielle, is showing clear success against targets with your results on your entry form – and to make the financial objective clear from the very outset.  

And ensuring that there’s a clear focus on demonstrating why this appeal is different.  It doesn’t need to represent something brand new to the sector but you must be able to show that it’s different for you – and that it’s made a difference.  It’s also really important to be able to identify what others can learn for it – as surely a key point to awards like this is to allow fundraisers to learn from each other and develop their own work?  So make sure your entry shows transferability.

Adrian believes that the campaigns that do make the grade are usually ones which have not only achieved great results, but have used great creative to do so.  At the heart of good fundraising, he explains, is an understanding of who donors are and what they want to see – and recognition that we are not the target audience!  He also talked about the importance of knowing when to engage external partners, to understand that while we may be experts at fundraising, there are added dimensions that the right partner agency can bring to help us see outside of our own understanding of “our donors”.

Some people are suspicious of awards, seeing them as an exercise in, in Adrian’s words, “mutual backslapping”.  But for Adrian, even the act of entering is a valuable exercise – to spend time, reflecting, to communicate succinctly to external people exactly what the challenges were and why the campaign was so successful, and to crystallise months’ worth of work into a few hundred words is a valuable discipline.  And, he says, it’s “great to be recognised” for the good work that you are doing. 

Danielle agrees.  She enters awards in part to recognise the hard work of her team, to demonstrate to them that their managers and the organisation they work for values them and the effort they put in to running their appeals.  It means a lot to her and her team to be shortlisted: “the rush to see who you're up against - but also to see what esteemed company you are keeping! But the pride that knowing your work is worthy of being shortlisted is great”.

Katia echoes Danielle on this point, talking about the enormous efforts across a whole organisation that goes into running a successful campaign – and often huge input from multiple agency partners too – she says “it’s brilliant for so much effort (and such great results) to be recognised”.

Whatever your views on the merits of awards, I hope you have found something on the shortlist to inspire you in your fundraising.  I’m looking forward to being there on the night and celebrating all that’s great about our sector – and hoping against hope for a win!  


Lisa Clavering 
 

Monday, 11 February 2013

The Summit, not Giles, is what we wanted to discuss



So The Summit has been cancelled. As you may know, I blogged on here a few weeks ago questioning the lineup after many people on Twitter commented that there was only one woman speaking and all speakers are employed by agencies. 

The Summit opened up, I think, a much needed debate about equality and how even in our sector, women still seem invisible at times. (In fact, the whole raison d’etre of Charity Chicks). Sadly the point about the speakers all being from agencies seemed to get lost and was never really discussed.

I think it is an equally valid point and one I would love to see debated with the same passion at some point.

Now I love a good debate and I love Twitter. One of the great things about social media, and in particular Twitter and blogging, is it gives anyone a voice. Which is fantastic. It makes it a great and exciting time to be a fundraiser, and a great and exciting time to be a person interested in the world around you. 

Giles Pegram took to Twitter to respond and I personally was pleased to see him do so. Debate is not debate when it is one sided. 

In fact, I would have loved to have seen the other speakers join in and discuss! (At least four are on Twitter at the last look).

Now the problem with Twitter is it gives a voice to anyone as long as they have the knack of commenting in 140 characters or less. It is a great place to spark debate but not necessarily the best place to finish a debate. 

Giles said some stuff on Twitter that was then incorporated into a news article. Taken away from Twitter and printed in black and white it looked pretty shocking and offensive. Put back into Twitter and in the context of short, snappy, 140 character responses it looked more like clumsy, but at least engaged, debate. 

Tania Mason of Civil Society then spoke to Giles to get his opinion - away from the Twittersphere, and in person. Giles then made some widely reported comments, for which he has subsequently apologised. 

Whilst, sadly, none of the other Summit contributors felt able to engage in the debate from what I can see, I do feel, and suspect many other people involved in this debate feel the same way, that Giles has been made into the face of this issue.

Giles has given so much to our sector and is great fighter for equality. The Summit, not Giles, is what we wanted to discuss. And The Summit is an example of the problem, but not the problem. There is so much to discuss and improve around the issue of diversity in our sector.  

BUT The Summit put itself out there as wanting to solve the crisis in our sector for us. That is a bold statement and one that, in this social media age, is inviting itself to be discussed, challenged and argued over. People on Twitter had every right to question the lineup and Charity Chicks had every right to blog about it.

So I was a little surprised to see The Agitator so agitated this morning that The Summit has been cancelled. The idea that asking important questions about The Summit is a firing squad seems a bit over the top to me and the comment about ‘a giant nibbled at the heels by dwarfs,’ is, I think, pretty offensive to the fundraisers out there who wanted to comment. 

But the Agitators are entitled to their opinion just as much as we at Charity Chicks are entitled to ours.

In fact the very first comment on the article is questioning how anyone can claim to be a feminist and refer to themselves as ‘chicks’. I happily call myself both a feminist and a charity chick and don’t see a problem with it. 

However we didn’t set up a blog for everyone to agree with everything we said and tell us how great we are. Criticism is an important part of helping this blog get better. 

So with this in mind, I think it is a shame The Summit was cancelled. I hope that it does happen at some point and the comments, concerns and yes, criticism, of it are taken into account and it comes back bigger, better and stronger. 

Kathryn Brooke